Retina tissue validation of optical coherence tomography determined outer nuclear layer loss in FTLD-tau
Acta Neuropathologica Communications volume 9, Article number: 184 (2021)
Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is associated with inner retina (nerve fiber and ganglion cell layers) thinning. In contrast, we have seen outer retina thinning driven by photoreceptor outer nuclear layer (ONL) thinning with antemortem optical coherence tomography (OCT) among patients considered to have a frontotemporal degeneration tauopathy (FTLD-Tau). Our objective was to determine if postmortem retinal tissue from FTLD-Tau patients demonstrates ONL loss observed antemortem on OCT. Two probable FTLD-Tau patients that were deeply phenotyped by clinical and genetic testing were imaged with OCT and followed to autopsy. Postmortem brain and retinal tissue were evaluated by a neuropathologist and ocular pathologist, respectively, masked to diagnosis. OCT findings were correlated with retinal histology. The two patients had autopsy-confirmed FTLD-Tau neuropathology and had antemortem OCT measurements showing ONL thinning (66.9 μm, patient #1; 74.9 μm, patient #2) below the 95% confidence interval of normal limits (75.1–120.7 μm) in our healthy control cohort. Postmortem, retinal tissue from both patients demonstrated loss of nuclei in the ONL, matching ONL loss visualized on antemortem OCT. Nuclei counts from each area of ONL loss (2 – 3 nuclei per column) seen in patient eyes were below the 95% confidence interval (4 – 8 nuclei per column for ONL) of 3 normal control retinas analyzed at the same location. Our evaluation of retinal tissue from FTLD-Tau patients confirms ONL loss seen antemortem by OCT. Continued investigation of ONL thinning as a biomarker that may distinguish FTLD-Tau from other dementias is warranted.
Tauopathies are a class of frontotemporal lobar degeneration proteinopathies (FTLD-Tau) commonly associated with frontotemporal dementia (FTD) syndromes. Clinical distinction of FTLD-Tau from other FTLD-associated proteinopathies (i.e. FTLD-TDP, FTLD-FUS) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is challenging . Thus, non-invasive biomarkers indicative of histologic features of FTLD-Tau are urgently needed to improve diagnosis and facilitate therapeutic trials.
Optical coherence tomography (OCT) enables visualization of neuronal tissue in vivo. Many studies have found inner retina thinning (nerve fiber and ganglion cell layer) in AD vs. controls . In contrast, our OCT studies revealed outer retina thinning with normal inner retina thicknesses in living FTD patients with clinical features or genetic mutations predictive of FTLD-Tau pathology [12, 13, 18]. The outer retina thinning is driven by loss of the outer nuclear layer (ONL), which consists of photoreceptor nuclei and composes most of the outer retina’s thickness. This outer retina thinning correlates with global cognitive impairment, and longitudinal OCT analysis found persistent and progressive ONL thinning among the probable FTLD-Tau patients [12, 13].
Postmortem retinal tissue confirmation of antemortem OCT findings is paramount to the potential development of OCT as a biomarker, but this data is lacking in FTD. Here, we report the first 2 consecutive autopsy findings of our OCT imaged FTLD-Tau patients for important postmortem validation.
Patients were followed in a clinical research program at the Penn Frontotemporal Degeneration Center (FTDC) and Scheie Eye Institute of the University of Pennsylvania. Clinical diagnosis was established at FTDC using modern clinical criteria for FTD syndromes at weekly consensus meetings as previously described [12, 13]. Patients had genetic testing for pathogenic mutations in MAPT (OMIM: 157140), progranulin (GRN) (OMIM:138945), C9orf72 (OMIM: 61426), and other FTD related genes based on pedigree analysis as previously described . Ophthalmic evaluation included a full, dilated eye exam by a retina specialist (BJK). All patients had no history of disease that would affect retinal thickness measurements, including diabetes, retinal or optic nerve disease, high refractive error (± 6.00 diopter spherical equivalent), or intraocular surgery (e.g. cataract surgery) within 90 days of the eye exam. Procedures for the OCT protocol, and neuropathological diagnosis have been previously described [12, 13, 19]. Briefly, patients were imaged with a standard spectral-domain OCT protocol using the Heidelberg Spectralis (Franklin, MA, USA). Each patient had a macular volume scan with 20 degree images, 25 raster scans, and automated real time averaging of 25 scans for each raster scan. While masked to clinical information, an analyst then segmented the retinal layers using the automated Iowa Reference Algorithm (v3.6), and segmentation errors were manually corrected [1, 6, 10]. Retinal layer thickness measurements were reported after averaging the values of the central 5 regions of the ETDRS (Early Treatment of Diabetic Retinopathy Study) grid.
Autopsies were performed at the Center for Neurodegenerative Disease Research with post-mortem intervals < 12 h. At autopsy, eyes and brain were collected. Independent evaluation of eyes and brains was performed by an ophthalmic pathologist (VL) and neuropathologist (EBL), respectively. Eyes were fixed in 10% formalin, processed, and paraffin embedded; five μm sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin. The ophthalmic pathologist performed histologic retinal evaluation while masked to clinical and neuropathological diagnosis. Representative sections of the whole eye were reviewed. As the study goal was to validate ONL loss seen on OCT, the evaluation of slides was directed towards the macula, where each eye was sectioned serially at multiple levels of the macula and evaluated in a uniform fashion.
Nuclei counts for the inner nuclear layer (INL) and ONL are an accepted way to evaluate retinal tissue [2, 16, 22]. In contrast, ganglion cell layer nuclei counts are known to have wide variability among normals , making them difficult to compare within small groups. After identifying areas of suspected macular ONL thinning, 20 – 30 columns of ONL and INL nuclei were counted at intervals of 10 microns. As measurements are affected by retinal location [2, 16, 22], the nuclei counts for each eye were then compared to ONL and INL nuclei counts at macular areas of equivalent size, location, and distance from the optic nerve from 3 different normal controls. Controls were 3 consecutive eyes obtained from the National Disease Research Interchange (Philadelphia, PA) and were from 3 subjects with no history of eye disease that would affect the retina, diabetes, or a neurodegenerative condition.
Suspected nuclei loss, either on OCT or histopathology, was considered abnormal if the measurement was outside the 95% confidence interval (95%CI) of normal limits using the normal approximation method (e.g., mean ± (1.96 X standard deviation)). Normal references were calculated for OCT data using previously reported control data , and they were calculated for retinal tissue nuclei counts from the 3 normal control retinas, yielding a normal range consistent with published nuclei counts of normal retinas .
This study was approved by the University of Pennsylvania Institutional Review Board and followed the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. All patients gave written informed consent (with caregivers if indicated).
Clinical evaluation and imaging
Patient #1 was a 63-year-old Caucasian woman diagnosed with progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) after 3 years of progressive L-DOPA resistant Parkinsonism, falls, and executive limitations with later emerging expressive language deficits. OCT was performed prior to this patient enrolling in a trial (NCT03068468) for PSP; she received gosuranemab (Biogen), a humanized antibody that binds N-terminal tau. Her symptoms progressed to end-stage dementia and death at age 67. Patient #2 was a 58-year-old Caucasian woman diagnosed with the behavioral variant of FTD (bvFTD) after 5 years of progressive cognitive and behavioral symptoms, as well as features of single-word and object knowledge later in her disease course from severe anterior temporal lobe disease. She had a pathogenic mutation in MAPT (E10 + 16 C > T mutation) and declined clinically with features of Parkinsonism and mutism with death at age 64 from end-stage dementia.
Each patient’s antemortem ophthalmic exam was normal and OCT images showed no known eye disease. With our imaging protocol, normal thicknesses for the retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL), ganglion cell layer (GCL), and outer nuclear layer (ONL) thickness are 23 μm, 41 μm, and 98 μm, respectively . As shown in Table 1, these patients had normal inner retina (RNFL and GCL) thicknesses. However, both patients had ONL thinning which was outside the 95% confidence interval thickness in our normal controls  (66.9 μm for left eye of patient 1 and 74.9 μm for right eye of patient 2), while the contralateral eye had thinning approaching statistical significance, especially for patient #2. With MRI, patient #1 demonstrated asymmetric frontal lobe atrophy (Fig. 1), and patient #2 had more widespread frontotemporal atrophy bilaterally (Fig. 2).
Postmortem brain examination of patient #1 demonstrated tau-positive threads, tufted astrocytes, coiled bodies, and perivascular vesicular astrocytes consistent with PSP with immunotherapy treatment effect (Fig. 1) . Patient #2 exhibited tau-positive pretangles, tangles, grains, and coiled bodies consistent with her known MAPT mutation (Fig. 2).
Evaluation of the retinas revealed no inner retina abnormalities. Histologically, outer retina health is commonly measured by ONL nuclei thickness. Normal maculas in the 6th–7th decade of life typically have about 6 layers of ONL nuclei . For patient #1, the right eye did not have appreciable ONL loss, but the left eye had definite ONL loss (range of 2–4 layers of nuclei) at the inferior macula, where the most ONL thinning was seen by OCT (Fig. 1). Both eyes of Patient #2 had ONL loss (range of 2–4 layers of nuclei) within the macula corresponding to OCT findings (Fig. 2 shows left eye).
When each of these areas of ONL loss were compared to equivalent macular locations in 3 normal controls (Table 2), the ONL nuclei counts were below the 95% confidence interval of controls (Table 3), but the INL nuclei counts of these areas were within the normal range.
Although OCT is considered highly reproducible, there is some variability or conflicting reports on OCT findings in neurodegenerative diseases. This is contributed to, in part, by the need for gold-standard autopsy confirmation to validate the patient’s specific underlying disease. This is especially true for the heterogeneous spectrum of FTLD. Therefore, tissue confirmation of OCT findings is critically important. We have presented novel and rare postmortem histopathological analysis of retinal tissue digitally quantified using OCT during life and correlated with underlying FTLD neuropathologic diagnosis. Our tissue data corroborates an outer retina abnormality seen on OCT among dementia patients. In comparison, other studies have shown retinal tissue with inner retina loss for AD  and normal OCT outer retina thickness in AD patients vs. controls .
While these patients presented with different clinical syndromes associated with tauopathies, our autopsy data aligns with our published OCT data suggesting a link between ONL thinning and FTLD-Tau, independent of clinical diagnosis [12, 13]. For each of the FTLD-Tau patients, significant ONL thinning was seen but there was some asymmetry with milder trends in the contralateral eye, especially for patient #1 who also had asymmetry of cortical atrophy on MRI. Indeed, FTLD microscopic pathology and antemortem atrophy often is distributed asymmetrically in the cortex [9, 17] and may influence the mild laterality of OCT data in our sample here. Nonetheless, we observed significant ONL loss postmortem that corresponds to in vivo OCT data. Our observations of areas of ONL loss were supported further by an analysis of nuclei counts showing abnormally low nuclei counts within the ONL, but normal nuclei counts within the nearby INL compared to controls. The mechanisms for tau-mediated neurodegeneration affecting the ONL are unclear, but tau has been shown within human photoreceptors . While the cause of ONL thinning is unknown, it may reflect phosphorylated tau toxicity related to the unusual amount of oxidative stress photoreceptors encounter . Among FTLD-Tau patients, oxidative stress may promote the phosphorylation of tau within photoreceptors, which in turn may have a toxic effect on photoreceptors and explain preferential damage to photoreceptors as opposed to other neuronal cells of the retina.
The small number of cases is the primary limitation of this data and deserves emphasis. Nevertheless, we believe our rare brain and eye autopsy data from these consecutive cases is compelling as it is entirely consistent with our prior studies suggesting ONL thinning in FTLD-Tau. There was limited availability of normal control retinal tissue, and the eyes were from subjects of greater age than the FTLD-Tau patients. However, these subjects had nuclei counts within the expected normal range, and age is associated with mild ONL loss (not an increase) , providing a fair comparison to our patients to support the finding of significant ONL loss. We also acknowledge that patient #1 received anti-tau immunotherapy with unclear effects on underlying biology and patient #2 had hereditary tauopathy. Thus, additional autopsy samples are needed to confirm findings, test generalization for sporadic tauopathies, and contrast with clinically similar AD and FTLD-TDP.
To our knowledge, these data are the first human tissue confirmation of OCT abnormalities in FTD, and the first tissue confirmation of an outer retina abnormality seen in dementia patients examined and imaged with OCT during life. These data support the continued investigation of retina imaging as a biomarker that may distinguish FTLD-Tau patients from other dementias including Alzheimer’s disease.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Frontotemporal lobar degeneration tauopathy
Frontotemporal lobar degeneration TAR DNA binding protein 43
Ganglion cell layer
Inner nuclear layer
Optical coherence tomography
Outer nuclear layer
Progressive supranuclear palsy
Retinal nerve fiber layer
Abramoff MD, Garvin MK, Sonka M (2010) Retinal imaging and image analysis. IEEE Rev Biomed Eng 3:169–208
Baumann BH, Shu W, Song Y, Sterling J, Kozmik Z, Lakhal-Littleton S et al (2019) Liver-specific, but not retina-specific, hepcidin knockout causes retinal iron accumulation and degeneration. Am J Pathol 189(9):1814–1830
Chan VTT, Sun Z, Tang S, Chen LJ, Wong A, Tham CC et al (2019) Spectral domain-optical coherence tomography measurements in Alzheimer’s disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ophthalmology 126(4):497–510. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ophtha.2018.08.009
Fridlich R, Delalande F, Jaillard C, Lu J, Poidevin L, Cronin T et al (2009) The thioredoxin-like protein rod-derived cone viability factor (RdCVFL) interacts with TAU and inhibits its phosphorylation in the retina. Mol Cell Proteom 8(6):1206–18. https://doi.org/10.1074/mcp.M800406-MCP200
Gartner S, Henkind P (1981) Aging and degeneration of the human macula. 1. Outer nuclear layer and photoreceptors. Br J Ophthalmol 65(1):23–28
Garvin MK, Abramoff MD, Wu X, Russell SR, Burns TL, Sonka M (2009) Automated 3-D intraretinal layer segmentation of macular spectral-domain optical coherence tomography images. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 28:1436–1447
Hinton DR, Sadun AA, Blanks JC, Miller CA (1986) Optic-nerve degeneration in Alzheimer’s disease. N Engl J Med 315:485–487. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM198608213150804
Irwin DJ, Cairns NJ, Grossman M, McMillan CT, Lee EB, Van Deerlin VM et al (2015) Frontotemporal lobar degeneration: defining phenotypic diversity through personalized medicine. Acta Neuropathol 129:469–491
Irwin DJ, McMillan CT, Xie SX, Rascovsky K, Van Deerlin VM, Coslett HB et al (2018) Asymmetry of post-mortem neuropathology in behavioural-variant frontotemporal dementia. Brain 141:288–301
Kang L, Wu X, Chen DZ, Sonka M (2006) Optimal surface segmentation in volumetric images: a graph-theoretic approach. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell 28:119–134
Kim B, Mikytuck B, Suh E, Gibbons GS, Van Deerlin VM, Vaishnavi SN et al (2021) Tau immunotherapy is associated with glial responses in FTLD-Tau. Acta Neuropathol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00401-021-02318-y
Kim BJ, Irwin DJ, Song D, Daniel E, Leveque JD, Raquib AR et al (2017) Optical coherence tomography identifies outer retina thinning in frontotemporal degeneration. Neurology 89:1604–1611. https://doi.org/10.1212/WNL.0000000000004500
Kim BJ, Grossman M, Song D, Saludades S, Pan W, Dominguez-Perez S et al (2019) Persistent and progressive outer retina thinning in frontotemporal degeneration. Front Neurosci 13:298
Kim SY, Sadda S, Pearlman J, Humayun MS, de Juan E, Melia BM et al (2002) Morphometric analysis of the macula in eyes with disciform age-related macular degeneration. Retina 22(4):471–477
Leger F, Fernagut P, Canron M, Leoni S, Vital C, Tison F et al (2011) Protein aggregation in the aging retina. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 70(1):63–68
Masri RA, Weltzien F, Purushothuman S, Lee SCS, Martin PR, Grunert U (2021) Composition of the inner nuclear layer in human retina. Invest Oph Vis Sci 62(9):22
Mesulam MM, Weintraub S, Rogalski EJ, Wieneke C, Geula C, Bigio EH (2014) Asymmetry and heterogeneity of Alzheimer’s and frontotemporal pathology in primary progressive aphasia. Brain 137:1176–1192
Sun JQ, McGeehan B, Firn K, Irwin D, Grossman M, Ying GS et al (2020) Comparison of the Iowa Reference Algorithm to the Heidelberg Spectralis optical coherence tomography segmentation algorithm. J Biophotonics 13:e201960187. https://doi.org/10.1002/jbio.201960187
Toledo JB, Van Deerlin VM, Lee EB, Suh ER, Baek Y, Robinson JL et al (2014) A platform for discovery: The University of Pennsylvania Integrated Neurodegenerative Disease Biobank. Alzheimers Dement 10(4):477–484
Uchida A, Pillai JA, Bermel R, Bonner-Jackson A, Rae-Grant A, Fernandez H et al (2018) Outer retinal assessment using spectral-domain optical coherence tomography in patients with alzheimer’s and parkinson’s disease. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 59:2768–2777. https://doi.org/10.1167/iovs.17-23240
Wood EM, Falcone D, Suh E, Irwin DJ, Chen-Plotkin AS, Lee EB et al (2013) Development and validation of pedigree classification criteria for frontotemporal lobar degeneration. JAMA Neurol 70(11):1411–1417. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamaneurol.2013.3956 (PMID: 24081456)
Zhao L, Wang C, Song D, Li Y, Song Y, Su G et al (2014) Systemic Administration of the Antioxidant/Iron Chelator alpha-Lipoic Acid Protects Against Light-Induced Photoreceptor Degeneration in the Mouse Retina. Invest Oph Vis Sci 55:5979–5988
Supported by NIH (Bethesda, MD) grants including AG017586, NS053488, AG052943, 2-P30-EY01583-26, K08-EY025742 (to V.L.), NS109260 (to D.J.I.), P01-AG066597 (to M.G.) Penn Institute on Aging, and P30-AG072979 (to E.B.L.). Funding was also provided in the form of block grants for general research purposes to the Scheie Eye Institute by Research to Prevent Blindness (New York, NY) and the Paul and Evanina Mackall Foundation Trust (Chicago, IL).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the University of Pennsylvania Institutional Review Board (#819894). All patients (or caregivers when appropriate) gave informed consent for this study.
Consent for publication
The cases described are of patients that have expired. Consent for publication has been given by the appropriate family member of each patient.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Kim, B.J., Lee, V., Lee, E.B. et al. Retina tissue validation of optical coherence tomography determined outer nuclear layer loss in FTLD-tau. acta neuropathol commun 9, 184 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40478-021-01290-8